Print This Post Print This Post

Drug Companies and Health Care - Foxes in the Henhouse

November 26th, 2008 Posted by David Lemberg

In July 2008 the American Academy of Pediatrics recommended that some children as young as 8 be treated aggressively with cholesterol-lowering drugs.

More recently, in the November 20th, 2008 edition of the New England Journal of Medicine,
researchers recommended that statins be prescribed for millions of healthy people with normal cholesterol levels.

Needless to say, the NEJM study – in which patients were given the statin Crestor – was funded by AstraZeneca, which manufactures Crestor.

First, can you spell conflict-of-interest? The AAP recommendations and the Crestor study conclusions are irresponsible at best. At worst, well, I don’t want to go there.

Beyond that, what’s going on here?

We live in a culture of denial of responsibility. No one is responsible for anything.

  • “Twinkies made me do it.”
  • I had PMS.”
  • “I have bad genes.”
  • “It’s not my fault.”

A person’s relative balance of health and disease is usually evaluated on the same basis.

  • Who is responsible for a lifelong two-pack-a-day smoker developing lung cancer? The tobacco company, of course.
  • Who is responsible for someone gaining 50 pounds in a year? Well, the fast food chain is responsible.
  • Who is responsible for hundreds of thousands of Americans developing diabetes each year? Candy manufacturers, naturally. Throw in doughnut-makers, too.

I’ll propose a radical concept - people are actually responsible for their own actions. Going further, in many cases people are responsible for the diseases and disorders they develop. It’s not that I’m a bad person, but I may be making choices that aren’t in my own best interests.

Lifestyle medicine is a relatively new term being used by many medical researchers and medical practitioners. From a lifestyle medicine perspective, many cases of diabetes, overweight and obesity, and high blood levels of cholesterol are caused by lifestyle choices. High-fat diets, high-sugar diets, lack of daily fruits and vegetables, and lack of exercise will cause people to develop diabetes, obesity, and high cholesterol.

Lifestyle medicine is directed at causing people to choose healthy behaviors.

So taking statins when you’re healthy to prevent high cholesterol and associated cardiovascular and inflammatory disorders makes no sense. Giving medicines – whose long-term effects are largely unknown – to children makes even less sense.

Am I going to choose risky behaviors, causing me to possibly need medication down the road, or am I going to choose a healthy lifestyle and take responsibility for my own health and well-being?

Yes, statins like Crestor and Lipitor have helped millions of adults with serious health problems. Still, taking these meds is like slamming the barn door after the horse has run away.

Let’s see. If I’m healthy now, will I choose to maintain my good health by regular exercise, a consistent healthy food plan, and sufficient rest. Or will I take a bunch of drugs, let the medication hijack my formerly finely tuned metabolism, and hope it all works out like the study said?

The choice seems clear.

Technorati Tags: , , ,

  1. 4 Responses to “Drug Companies and Health Care - Foxes in the Henhouse”

  2. I think 8 years old is very young to choose medicine over teaching healthy life habits. An overall approach is certainly better.

    By HealthNut on Nov 29, 2008

  3. This is such a great article. I am really glad i came upon it.

    I 100% agree with more all less the whole of it.

    I think the whole culture of blaiming stupid things needs to be cut. Parents need to take some responsibility for all of this, they are allowing and buying kids all this junk and then wonder why they get obese.

    Obesity is draining our national health here in the UK. I know some people have eating disorders, and other problems which can cause obesity through no fault, but i would say the majority are just not taking care.

    Drug companies will always try and cash in. I personally dont think we should pump kids with drugs, as then they will think they can eat crap and take the drugs.

    Get them to the gym on a good and recomended workout

    By jeff@Homemade Beauty Tips on Dec 9, 2008

  4. Fixing obesity with drugs is like patching a leaky bucket, then repatching and repatching it as new problems pop up as a result of the drugs.

    The problem really needs to be addressed at the source, by tackling attitudes to food and exercise.

    By James@Pharmacy Cheltenham on Jul 31, 2009

  5. It sounds like a bit of gold old cost benefit analysis. The cost of giving everyone statins probably worked out cheaper than the cost to the healthcare system of treating people with cholesterol related diseases.

    By John@Charlton Pharmacy on Sep 7, 2009

Post a Comment